All Commentary
Friday, September 2, 2016

Mises’s Treatise on Socialism that Keeps on Giving

There Is more to Mises's book Socialism than you think

Ludwig von Mises’s Socialism (1922) is a legendary classic, but sometimes that can be the worst possible fate to befall a work. It’s a tragic thing when a great work becomes a symbol or a slogan, rather than something people really study and learn from. Based on an informal poll I’ve taken among self-professed Mises fans (“Have you actually read Socialism?”), I fear that this is what has happened to this book.

The answer must have come to Mises at some point in 1919.This is not a book for the shelves. It is a book to read and engage right now, right where you are. It is a book that explains vast amounts of the reality we are living right now. It works as a decoder to today’s headlines.

How can that be? Most people assume that socialism has somehow been defeated. Not so. It has spread out all over the world in different forms. Mises’s book addresses every conceivable form of the socialist idea. He shows you how to find the errors in Obamacare, government-provided child care, migration controls, quantitative easing, protectionism, the education bubble, the U.S. imperial wars, environmentalism, the drug war, and so much more. There are insights on every page.

Vienna’s Socialists

To understand the significance of the work, you have to imagine this scene from Vienna in the early 1920s. Practically every important intellectual was a socialist. There were different varieties, left and right, but they all agreed that free markets had flopped and government planning was the scientific answer.

The brilliant young monetary economist Ludwig von Mises had just finished writing a book on World War I and its ghastly horrors. Why would Europe want to prolong the suffering of war? That’s what socialism would do, he realized. It would attack private property, make life impossible for business, wreck the ability of people to manage their own lives, and even threaten the integrity of money itself.

The problem and the answer required serious intellectual work. What could Mises say or write that would put an end to all this crazy dreaming about socialism?

The answer must have come to Mises at some point in 1919. He looked around at the real way that business struggled to provide society with goods and services. Socialism intended to take it all away.

Socialism Would Create Calamity

No book like it had ever appeared. He was not just swimming against the tide.Mises made his first case in a journal article that appeared in 1920. Jaws dropped. How could this intellectual attempt to resurrect what everyone knew was dead? How could he dare to dismiss what practically everyone believed in?

Two years passed. Mises’s article was gaining traction. Then the blockbuster book appeared. It was a full-scale analysis that covered far more than economics. This book covered war, taxation, family, money, trade, medical care, education, the environment. Once the model was in place, he found a thousand applications. His conclusion violated every taboo. Socialism in all its forms leads to waste, confusion, poverty, and the end of civilization, he wrote; only free markets can satisfy the demands of economic rationality.

No book like it had ever appeared. He was not just swimming against the tide. He was condemning the whole of the intellectual trend the world over. And he did it with astonishing clarity and sweeping comprehensiveness. No subject area was left untouched, not even monetary policy.

Mises might as well have been addressing the Fed when he condemned how loose money and manipulation destroy the signaling system of the interest rate. Quantitative easing “leads everyone to consume his fortune; it discourages saving, and thereby prevents the formation of fresh capital.” It drains money from real enterprise to pour it into finance capital, thereby giving rise to “popular frenzy” to smash the capitalists.

If this is your first time to encounter the book, don’t skip the opening chapters. To be sure, central bankers don’t think of themselves as socialists. But socialism doesn’t just mean nationalization of capital. It can be the nationalization of money and the attempt to plan monetary policy the way the Soviets tried to plan wheat production. This is the pedigree. All government controls stem from the same intellectual root. They all threaten freedom, the market order, and civilization itself.

Theory of Society

If this is your first time to encounter the book, don’t skip the opening chapters. Reflect on them deeply because they posit a fascinating theory of society and property. Mises accomplishes this without recourse to the Lockean tradition and instead chooses a more anthropological/historical outlook.

He treats private property not as a command that came down from on high but rather an evolved technology growing out of real human experience. Nature does not provide enough to care for a growing population. Production is a requirement for life. Private property represented a discovery of a means of sustaining life itself. The entire section represents an intriguing challenge to the traditional way of thinking about this topic.

Then there are the sections on the family, sexuality, religion, labor rights, the welfare state, primitivism, destructionism, and so very much more. It’s all so wonderful.

How is it possible that Mises’s Socialism would have lost none of its power after 95 years? That’s the mark of brilliance. Even now, the book amounts to a scientific but searing attack on nearly every political ideology except that which grants people the right to use their property as they see fit.