All Commentary
Saturday, August 11, 2018

Economic Turnaround: Pittsburgh Rebuilds and Rebrands

Pittsburgh's recovery is an inspirational economic success story that others should look to imitate.

Fireworks over Pittsburgh

The collapse of the U.S. steel industry in the 1980s sent once-thriving Pittsburgh into a severe economic depression.

Pittsburgh has struggled to rebuild and rebrand itself for decades. Yet the city today is not the crumbling, desolate place one might expect.

From Rust Belt Bygone to Burgeoning Tech Hub

The city has been transforming itself from an industrial economy based on steel to a manufacturing economy based on innovation and technology. The newly established competitive advantage of the Pittsburgh region is its high-skilled workers, top-notch research institutions, and technology-intense advanced manufacturing.

The region lost 133,000 manufacturing jobs between 1979 and 1987.

This evolving shift has been enabled by key factors, although implementing more conservative, free-market conservative policies would achieve greater results.

The region lost 133,000 manufacturing jobs between 1979 and 1987, and the unemployment rate grew to more than 15 percent.

In 2003, Pittsburgh was designated as financially distressed under Act 47, a Pennsylvania law that provides a broad-based program of fiscal management oversight and other technical assistance.

Under the statute, Pittsburgh restructured employee benefits, enacted fiscal reforms, and cut its workforce by more than 20 percent. In February of this year, the city exited the program.

Individual Leadership and Philanthropy

Also notable is the endurance of some free-market ideas promoted and epitomized by the businessmen who made their fortunes in Pittsburgh—Carnegie, Mellon, and Heinz, among others.

The Mellon family, for example, left a legacy of philanthropy to institutions such as Carnegie Mellon University and the University of Pittsburgh.

Leadership from such individuals enabled Pittsburgh to survive and regenerate.

Andrew W. Mellon, who The Economist once described as “arguably the least-known and most under-appreciated,” valued free enterprise and self-reliance. A foundation in his name promotes the humanities and supports higher education.

Leadership from such individuals enabled Pittsburgh to survive and regenerate. Their resources helped build research-focused institutions and played a key role in allowing residents the opportunity to learn new skills.

The city’s knowledge institutions gradually expanded to form the core of its cutting-edge “global innovation economy.”

Besides its success in research, Pittsburgh’s five largest sectors—advanced manufacturing, health care, energy, financial services, and information technology—together form a more diverse economy. Large corporations such as Google, Uber, Apple, Facebook, and Amazon are opening offices and testing new products.

The road back from economic devastation in the Rust Belt will not be easy. But Pittsburgh’s turnaround is a case that can be studied and inspire some good ideas in other cities.

Reprinted from the Daily Signal.

  • Anthony B. Kim researches international economic issues at The Heritage Foundation, with a strong focus on economic freedom. Kim is the research manager of the Index of Economic Freedom, the flagship product of the Heritage Foundation in partnership with The Wall Street Journal. Read his research.