I am not expecting a market in kidneys anytime soon, but ever more sophisticated barter is slowly improving kidney allocation. Most recently, UCLA has started a program where a kidney donation may be swapped for a kidney gift certificate that is good for a kidney transplant at a time of the recipient’s choosing.
The program allows for living donors to donate a kidney in advance of when a friend or family member might require a kidney transplant. ...
“It’s the brainchild of a grandfather who wanted to donate a kidney to his grandson nearing dialysis dependency, but the grandfather felt he would be too old to donate in a few years when his grandson would likely need a transplant.”
Nine other transplant centers across the U.S. have agreed to offer the gift certificate program, under the umbrella of the National Kidney Registry’s advanced donation program. Veale anticipates that more living donors will come forward to donate kidneys, which could trigger chains of transplants. Then, when a patient redeems his or her gift certificate, the last donor in the chain could donate a kidney to that recipient.
Improving allocation is important, but the real constraint today is supply. This program may help with that on the margin, however, because altruistic donors could donate and keep a gift certificate as insurance in case any of their family members one day need a transplant. More fundamentally, however, increasing supply will require some form of compensation or incentive such as "no-give, no-take."
- See also: "How to Get a Spare Kidney."