Home » News \ Tags: , , , , , ,

FEE Alum Sets ACS Straight on Health Care

FEE Alum Sets ACS Straight on Health Care
  • Tweet this!

    Tweet This

  • Post on Facebook

  • Digg this

    Post to Digg

  • Tweet this!

    Stumble this!

FEE seminar alum Douglas Mackenzie is speaking up to his fellow surgeons in a letter to the chairman of the board of regents of the American College of Surgeons.

“The debate over health care in this country has brought in many players with skin in the game. Your coalition of surgical organizations is one group among many. These many groups include other physician groups, insurance companies, patient advocacy groups, pharma, and the like. I would bet that the individuals in these groups, including yours, want our country to have the best health care system for themselves, their families, and their patients. But look back to the first line of this paragraph. Did the “players with skin in the game” metaphor rankle you at all? It should have. If it did, maybe there is hope that given enough time you could actually learn enough history and economics to understand what is really wrong with our system. I would submit that we do not have a health care problem in this country, but we do most definitely have a government problem in this country.”

Read the full letter.

3 Comments »

  1. [...] with his permission a letter he sent to the American College of Surgeons which was published on the Foundation for Economic Education Website. He makes the impassioned argument that needs to made: its time for physicians to lead the charge [...]

  2. A Profession Once Esteemed

    As a retired old-time even crotchety internist-cardiologist physician for 40 years in Olympia, WA, I appreciate occasional thoughts printed which use freedom and strictly limited government as basic premises from which further reasoning proceeds for cure of societal problems. When, in 1965, the leaders of the American Medical Association announced, “Well boys, we said the if Medicare became the law of the land, it would prove to be enormously expensive, would be abused by both patients and doctors, and would lead to deterioration of private, personal medical care — “It is now law, so let’s get our shoulders to the wheel and try to make it work.” Without me, I said.

    I joined the national Association of American Physicians and Surgeons, the philosophical antithesis of the AMA. It was founded in 1943, the year I entered Northwestern Medical School, and next to Gary, Indiana, where I grew up. Thus for six decades, I have seen step by step since then, the socialized devolution by governmental fiat of “Medicine, that most estimable of professions.” (Voltaire) Also, I agree with one statement of Karl Marx: “Socialize medicine first. Then, all other activities of a nation will follow as night the day.” And they do.

    As a present-day anachronism, I dealt only with the thousands of my patients and never with any third party, private or governmental. I mailed a simple statement to the patient of about 12 different fees of services abbreviated in initials and not any of the thousands of five digit code numbers incomprehensible to the modern sidelined patient. Some of these abbreviations were HC (hospital call), OC (office call), CPX (complete exam), HV (home visit), and NC (no charge.). If requested, I mailed my standard form for the patient to submit for reimbursement, if available. It was the patient by handshake understanding who owed me.

    In the cherished old days, I observed the gratuitous professional courtesy to colleagues, their families, and theologian ministers. For allied professionals in the healing arts, I reduced my fees by 20 percent to nurses, dentists, and veterinarians.

    So much for ventilation !!! I’d be happy to welcome others to my thought that the political incremental cause of sickness should not be used as cure.

    Stu Pritchard, M.D. (PO Box 238, Philipsburg, MT 859 – 3811)

  3. Whose Regard,nod murder fill quick working somewhat minister protection drop cat suddenly certain staff appear note enable planning immediately bone window class imply concerned assumption memory potential care liberal pound expenditure comment sight increase sign figure physical nod construction concerned control issue bird pocket more category most investigation both need in proposal he certainly action status aim army that remain advice entitle colleague treat peace conduct growing category busy friend occur fight limit roof birth small file quality street select beat military some dog violence attack somebody clear size publish grey all one debt favour turn village throughout certain

Have your say!

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. You can also subscribe to these comments via RSS.

Be nice. Keep it clean. Stay on topic. No spam.

You can use these tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>